Skip to content
FREE shipping on orders $149+
15% off the Thanksgiving table with code THANKS26 — order by Wed, Nov 12 →
THANKS26: 15% off Thanksgiving, order by Nov 12 →

Cooperstown Distillery - Spitball Cinnamon Whiskey

$38.99
$38.99 - $38.99
Current price $38.99

🚚 Ships for $9.95 · FREE over $149

Most online liquor stores charge $20+ to ship a bottle.

Earn 116 Tipxy Rewards points with this bottle. Create an account and start with 250.
Will it arrive for Thanksgiving? Enter your zip — we’ll check this bottle’s date

An adult 21+ must sign for delivery, with ID if asked. We can’t leave it at the door.

Tipsy Sauce - Caramel Hard Sauce
Pairs with this bottle Tipsy Sauce - Caramel Hard Sauce $24.95 · Liqueur sauce · Pre-order

Overview

More Info

This complex cinnamon whiskey is named “Spitball” as a nod to the controversial baseball pitch during the early days of the game. With 50% less sugar content than mass marketed competitors, whiskey connoisseurs can enjoy this spirit straight, on the rocks, or as a mixer in Manhattans or Whiskey Sours.

Tasting notes

An interestingly spicy spirit that caters to the cinnamon-flavored whiskey craze which has swept the country, this complex cinnamon whiskey is named “Spitball” as a nod to the controversial and ultimately outlawed baseball pitch during the early days of the game. Made from 3 types of cinnamon, it packs a powerful punch of heat, reminiscent of other cinnamon whiskey brands, but finishes with undertones of coffee, chocolate, and caramel.

Brand
Cooperstown Distillery
Size
750ml
ABV
35.00
Country
United States
Region
New York
Kosher
Unknown

Search with flavor attributes with our revolutionary Flavor Finder tool!

Distillery Experience

  • Distillery Tours
  • Distillery Tasting Rooms

Still Type

  • Custom German 28-gallon copper still
Loved by our community

What customers say about shopping with TIPXY

Read all reviews
Loved by our community

What customers say about shopping with TIPXY

Read all reviews

Tipxy AI Overview

What people across the internet are saying
★ ★ ★ ☆ ☆ 3/5 AI Rating

Reviewers on Caskers and distillery visitors praise Cooperstown Spitball — 50% less sugar than rivals, made with three types of cinnamon. The 70-proof palate balances cinnamon heat with caramel, vanilla, tobacco, and chocolate undertones. A small but enthusiastic positive reception, especially from baseball-themed gift buyers.

*This is an AI-generated summary based on publicly available reviews and discussions.